In fact, i have more than one theory. So you can believe any of them, or believe no one XD I made them when i was totally convinced that Sirius could not be dead. It simply couldn't. We were at the Ministry, turn the page and Sirius is dead. So i reread. And again. And a thousand times. Then, I cried, and decided he was not dead and he would come back in book 6. But he didn't...pity. But there is more...what if he is alive?
You never asked why on earth wasn't time turner used to go back and make sure Sirius did not die? And what on earth NO ONE had the idea while I WAS SHOUTING IT AT THE BOOK?? The answer is that: obviously there were those who realized they could use time turner. They could have gone to warn Sirius of his fate: he would not had gone to the Department of Mysteries. What if that really happened? What if someone took polyjuice potion, transformed into Sirius and went to the Department of Mysteries? But ...who cared so much about Sirius to do so? harry...and no one more. It is highly impossible then. But there's the possibility that someone saved Sirius. It means that it was very important that Sirius was considered dead. Or that Harry need s to think Sirius is dead. Why? Because being "alone" has done to Harry more good than harm: he is now very corageous! He knows that he is alone, and he himself is the only one who can defeat Voldemort. Being with Sirius would have done that Harry thought he was not prepared to do so.
It could be paranoia but what about the mood of the others in the order? aren't they a little too happy? what if they did knew what was about to happen? And another thing: what if the veil is nothing but a simple doorway, and everybody made harry believed it? If it it just a doorway Sirius could come back but didn't...
Bellatrix didn't kill him with the charm she made, as it was a stunner charm (not only a disarmer charm i think, though the light was red). But WHY did anyone TRY to rescue him? I mean, see what the veil is and try to go through it...
I think this is all a pantomina, and was created for Harry: he needs to think Sirius is Dead.
Sirius cared a lot about Harry, that was demonstraded so far in PoA and GoF, and what were the objective for these books if not to give Harry dreams and be loved?
I would explain you that i have some complementary theories to this, as is the one "who did use turn timer on sirius' death" and the one "Sirius and the Mirror"
Sirius was, is, and will always be my favorite character.(I like Ron very much but Sirius...Sirius is Sirius)
3 comentaris:
I think that your theory is very good. In fact, i read twice and i'm a little convinced about what you explain.
that would explain why dumbledore die in stupid way, yeah maybe you are right and there is a plan to convinced harry that he is alone, betrayed with Snape, but why if Rowling had made a mistake? i think it could be imposible, but you know that when you are writing there are things that can pass you away, i don't know if you know what i mean.
Bueno i com que ja me cansat d'escriure en anglès que me donat compte que el tinc olvidat i que com no me posi les piles l'any que ve me tocarà fe anglès, ja debatrem aquest tema a la uni! jeje.
Vinga maca un petonet!
id add that somehow dumbledore took the time turner and go forward in time in order to see what would happen and then came back, and as he knew it had to happen he took the polyjuice potion and told sirius to do it so...! and who was killed in 5th book was dumbledore not sirius!
Wait...dumbledore (sirius in fact) dies in 6th... DAMNED!
:D:D:D:D:D:D:D
(if you are to say stupid theories...may i help you? :P
yeah i liked that
hugs, hoping see you soon
look! i use smileys! or what they are
i discovered them few days ago -
Publica un comentari a l'entrada